Item 5c Memo

PORT OF SEATTLE 
MEMORANDUM 
COMMISSION AGENDA             Item No.      5c 
Date of Meeting   December 15, 2009 

DATE:    December 8, 2009 
TO:     Tay Yoshitani, Chief Executive Officer 
FROM:    Ralph Graves, Managing Director, Capital Development 
SUBJECT:  Change Order 001 for the Terminal 115 Berth 1Modifications Project,
MC-0316208 

ACTION REQUESTED
Request authorization for the Chief Executive Officer to execute Change Order 001 for
the T-115, Berth 1 Modifications Project for the Not to Exceed Net amount of $162,000. 
SYNOPSIS 
The T-115, Berth 1 Modifications Project advertised for public bid on August 07, 2009.
The tenant, Northland Terminal Services (NTS), requested a significant change in the
design of the A-Frame Ramp Lifting Mechanism just prior to bid date. NTS believed that
in an extreme low tide situation the ramp, as designed, would be unsafe to operate. In an
agreement made between the Port and NTS, the Port would accommodate the design
change if NTS provided a design acceptable to the Port and covered any additional cost
over the engineer's estimate of the original design. The Lift System was kept in the
Construction Bid and assigned a bid allowance of $310,000, to be credited to the
fabrication and construction costs of the NTS designed ramp lifting mechanism. The new
design affects the catwalk system and support system, resulting in an additional credit
back to the contract of $78,000. The Contractor, Pacific Pile and Marine, is currently
reviewing the revised documents and is pricing this change. To stay on schedule, a
change order is required to direct the contractor to implement this change. Based on the
additive and deductive elements of this design revision, a change order will be issued for
the not to exceed additional cost of $162,000.
The absolute value of the change order exceeds $300,000 ($938,000); therefore under
Resolution No. 3605, as amended, section 4.2.3.8, the change order requires approval.

COMMISSION AGENDA 
Tay Yoshitani, Chief Executive Officer 
December 10, 2009 
Page 2 of 3 
CHANGE ORDER DESCRIPTION AND JUSTIFICATION: 
The following information relates to the pending change order scope and cost: 
Change Order No. 001 
Scope of work: Fabricate and install ramp lifting mechanism as detailed by NTS
provided design and delete the ramp lifting mechanism, associated catwalks and
supports.  The estimated lead time needed to procure the winch may require an
extension to the contract end date. Currently that extension is estimated to be
approximately 47 days, however staff is still evaluating the time impact at this
time. It is not expected for the time impact to be greater than 60 days at this time.
To lessen the potential time impact, staff is inquiring if the contractor would be
willing to order the winch sooner. If so, a separate CO for approximately $70,000
will be issued. The amount of that CO will be deducted directly from the amount
below. 
Justification: The ramp lifting mechanism as represented in the bid documents,
designed in collaboration with NTS may create a hazardous situation during
extreme low tide events. NTS has provided an alternate design at their expense,
however not until after the award of the contract. 
Consequences of not proceeding: The ramp and associated lifting mechanism
will not be constructed. The Berth 1 project scope would be completed per
contract, but the berth would not be capable of being used for cargo operations. 

NTS Designed Ramp Lifting Mechanism (estimate)                  $550,000 
Delete Bid Item #39: Furnish & Install A-Frame Supports               ($52,000) 
Delete Bid Item #40: Furnish & Install A-Frame                    ($310,000) 
Delete Bid item #41: Furnish & Install Catwalk                      ($26,000) 
Net CO Not To Exceed Amount                          $162,000 

FINANCIAL ANALYSIS: 
Funds to pay for this change order are part of the project contingency funds that were
included in previously approved authorizations of $35,219,410. The Seaport Business
Unit has negotiated an agreement with NTS regarding the additional cost over $388,000.
No additional project funds are being requested as a result of this change order.

COMMISSION AGENDA 
Tay Yoshitani, Chief Executive Officer 
December 10, 2009 
Page 3 of 3 
CONTRACT INFORMATION: 
The following information relates to the contract and competitive award: 
Contract award date:                            October 5, 2009 
Original period of performance:         October 5, 2009 to April 15, 2010 
Previous contract extensions:                             0 Days 
Contract extension this change order:               47 Days (estimated) 
Current Contract Completion Date:                    June 1, 2010 
Original contract amount:                         $2,776,900.00 
Previous Change Order (none):                           $0.00 
Current contract amount                          $2,776,900.00 
This request, Change Order No. 001                    $162,000.00 
Revised contract amount:                        $2,964,900.00

Limitations of Translatable Documents

PDF files are created with text and images are placed at an exact position on a page of a fixed size.
Web pages are fluid in nature, and the exact positioning of PDF text creates presentation problems.
PDFs that are full page graphics, or scanned pages are generally unable to be made accessible, In these cases, viewing whatever plain text could be extracted is the only alternative.