Supp, SCM Supp
LEASE AND CONCESSION AUDIT INTERNAL AUDIT Puget Sound Dispatch LLC dba Yellow Cab BACKGROUND The Port entered into a five-year concession agreement, effective November 1, 2010, with PSD for "the non-exclusive right to provide transportation services from the Airport by way of On-Demand Taxi services" In exchange for the right, PSD agreed to pay Concession Fees of 13% of Gross Receipts generated in connection with the agreement or the Minimum Annual Guaranty of $3,670,778, whichever is higher. The Concession Agreement provides the following two methods to calculate gross receipts as the basis for Concession Fees: Based on total actual revenues derived from operations under the terms of the Agreement Or Based on other reasonably available information to Concessionaire where "...a precise determination of Concessionaire's total Gross Receipts may be difficult or impossible." Under this methodology, the Port and PSD agreed to determine the Gross Receipts by a formula: outbound trips x average fare = Gross Receipts. LEASE AND CONCESSION AUDIT INTERNAL AUDIT Puget Sound Dispatch LLC dba Yellow Cab BACKGROUND CONTINUED LEASE AND CONCESSION AUDIT INTERNAL AUDIT Puget Sound Dispatch LLC dba Yellow Cab AUDIT OBJECTIVES AND SCOPE The purpose of the audit was: 1. To determine whether Port management monitoring controls are adequate and effective to ensure: Puget Sound Dispatch (PSD) submits a detailed statement showing the Gross Receipts derived from the Concession Agreement and pay to the Port, if applicable, percentage fee in excess of the Minimum Annual Guarantee (MAG). 2. To determine whether PSD-reported MAG/Concession Fees were complete, properly calculated, and remitted timely to the Port. 3. To determine whether Port management and PSD complied with significant financial terms of the agreement. 4. To determine how the unique gross receipts provision, which allows the use of estimates, became part of the agreement. We reviewed and analyzed records for the entire Agreement period. For purposes of rendering our opinion, we focused on the period November 1, 2011 August 31, 2015. Under the Agreement record retention requirement, PSD is not required to retain records for periods prior to November 2011. LEASE AND CONCESSION AUDIT INTERNAL AUDIT Puget Sound Dispatch LLC dba Yellow Cab AUDIT RESULT Management monitoring controls over the Puget Sound Dispatch Concession Agreement were/are not adequate to ensure accurate and complete reporting of Concession Fees. Although PSD mathematically calculated Concession Fees properly and submitted the information timely, PSD-reported Concession Fees were not complete or accurate. Additionally, PSD did not comply with the record retention requirements in the Agreement. The origin of the unique Gross Receipts provision, which allows the use of estimates, is noted in the first and second paragraphs under the report Background. Three (3) Reportable Findings LEASE AND CONCESSION AUDIT INTERNAL AUDIT Puget Sound Dispatch LLC dba Yellow Cab AUDIT RESULT FINDING #1 1. Port Management Monitoring Controls Over The Puget Sound Dispatch (PSD) Agreement Are Inadequate And Ineffective. Port management did not have complete knowledge of the methodology used by PSD to calculate or estimate Gross Receipts reported to the Port. Management monitoring of taxicab activities was not adequate to reasonably ensure that all airport fleet vehicles were properly tagged with a functioning AVI ID. Management had no knowledge of how the zones were determined. Management did not understand or follow up on whether the method used was supported with data/information, or whether the established zones were reasonable and acceptable to the Port. Port management did not stay abreast of evolving and emerging applicable taxi regulations in King County. Trips by non-airport fleet taxicabs were not tracked. Port management had little interactions with PSD related to monthly financial reporting. Port management did not follow up on unusual trends and information. LEASE AND CONCESSION AUDIT INTERNAL AUDIT Puget Sound Dispatch LLC dba Yellow Cab AUDIT RESULT FINDING #2 2. Puget Sound Dispatch Reported Inaccurate And Incomplete Gross Receipts. PSD used two different methods during the audit period to calculate Gross Receipts as follows: During the period November 2011 March 2015, Gross Receipts were imputed based on a simple formula: Outbound Trip Count x Average Fare = Gross Receipts. Average Fare - no records to support this average fare estimation Outbound Trip Count incomplete information in support of the trips used in Gross Receipts calculations During the period April 2015 August 2015, PSD reported Gross Receipts based on data from its dispatch system. Incomplete reporting of trips, resulting in underreported Gross Receipts LEASE AND CONCESSION AUDIT INTERNAL AUDIT Puget Sound Dispatch LLC dba Yellow Cab AUDIT RESULT FINDING #3 3. Puget Sound Dispatch Did Not Comply With The Agreement Record Retention. PSD did not maintain a system of records in full support of the reported Gross Receipts and Concession Fees. Records were incomplete and/or missing for the audit period and did not comply with the 3-year retention requirement.
Limitations of Translatable Documents
PDF files are created with text and images are placed at an exact position on a page of a fixed size.
Web pages are fluid in nature, and the exact positioning of PDF text creates presentation problems.
PDFs that are full page graphics, or scanned pages are generally unable to be made accessible, In these cases, viewing whatever plain text could be extracted is the only alternative.