7a attach

Northwest Ports
Clean AirStrategy
2013 Update (DRAFT) | June 2013
DRAFT

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The Port of Seattle, Port of Tacoma, and Port Metro Vancouver jointly developed the Northwest
Ports Clean Air Strategy2013 Update with contributions from partner agencies. The ports
would like to thank the following agencies for their contributions:
Environment Canada
Metro Vancouver
Puget Sound Clean Air Agency
United State Environmental Protection Agency
Washington State Department of Ecology



Stephanie Jones Stebbins      Jason Jordan              Ronan Chester
206.787.3818      DRAFT                                253.830.5321               604.665.9311
jonesstebbins.s@portseattle.org    jjordan@portoftacoma.com        ronan.chester@portmetrovancouver.com
www.portseattle.org            www.portoftacoma.com          www.portmetrovancouver.com



Richard Holt               Dan Brown                Frank Van Haren
604.666.6552               503.326.6832               3360.407.6870
richard.holt@ec.gc.ca           brown.dan@epa.gov            fvan461@ecy.wa.gov
www.ec.gc.ca               www.epa.gov               www.ecy.wa.gov

Metro Vancouver
Shelina Sidi                      Andrew Green
604.436.6750                    206.689.4053
shelina.sidi@metrovancouver.org         andrewg@pscleanair.org
www.metrovancouver.org             www.pscleanair.org


DRAFT Northwest Ports Clean Air Strategy Update June 2013                                          ii

CONTENTS
Acknowledgments.......................................................................................................................... ii
Executive Summary......................................................................................................................1
Strategy Overview..........................................................................................................................5
Airshed Emission-Reduction Goals................................................................................................8
Performance Targets By Sector....................................................................................................10
1. Ocean-Going Vessels.........................................................................................................12
2. Harbor Vessels...................................................................................................................15
3. Cargo-Handling Equipment................................................................................................17
4. Trucks.................................................................................................................................19
5. Locomotives and Rail Transport.........................................................................................21
6. Port Administration.............................................................................................................23
Pilot Studies and Demonstration Projects....................................................................................25
Performance Reporting................................................................................................................27
Conclusions and Next Steps........................................................................................................28
Glossary.......................................................................................................................................29
Appendix A. Port Emissions Inventories.......................................................................................32
Appendix B. Air Emission Regulations in U.S. and Canada.........................................................37
Tables
Table 1. Summary of Actions and Performance Targets by Sector for 2015 and 2020...................2
Table 2. Emission-Reduction Goals for DPM and GHGs by 2015 and 2020..................................9
Table 3. Actions and Performance Targets for Ocean-Going Vessels...........................................14
Table 4. Actions and Performance Targets for Harbor Vessels.....................................................16
Table 5. Actions and Performance Targets for Cargo-Handling Equipment..................................18
Table 6. Actions and Performance Targets for Trucks...................................................................20
Table 7. Actions and Performance Targets for Locomotives and Rail Transport...........................22
Table 8. Actions and Performance Targets for Port Administration, for ........................................24
Table A-1. Port of Seattle2011 Emissions Inventory for Puget Sound Airshed (tons)................33
Table A-2. Port of SeattleChanges in Port Airshed Emissions from 2005 to 2011.....................33
Table A-3. Port of Tacoma2011 Emissions Inventory for Puget Sound Airshed (tons)...............34
Table A-4. Port of TacomaChanges in Port Airshed Emissions from 2005 to 2011....................34
Table A-5. Port Metro Vancouver2010 Emissions Estimates for Lower Fraser Valley Airshed .....36
Table B-1. Comparison of Air Emission Regulations in the United States and Canada................37                                                    DRAFT
Figures
Figure 1. Georgia Basin-Puget Sound Airshed Boundaries...........................................................6
Figure 2. Port-Related DPM and GHG Emissions by Sector from the Three Ports, 20102011....... 11
Figure A-1. Puget Sound Maritime Emissions Inventory Boundaries...........................................32
Figure A-2. Port Metro VancouverEmissions Inventory Boundaries.........................................35
iii
DRAFT Northwest Ports Clean Air Strategy Update June 2013

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The Port of Seattle, Port of Tacoma, and Port Metro Vancouver are continuing their collaborative
efforts on the Northwest Ports Clean Air Strategy to reduce emissions from shipping and
port operations in the Georgia BasinPuget Sound airshed. In developing and implementing
the 2007 Strategy and this 2013 Strategy Update, the three ports partnered with government
agencies including: Environment Canada and Metro Vancouver in Canada, and the U.S.
Environmental Protection Agency, Washington State Department of Ecology, and Puget Sound
Clean Air Agency in the United States. Collectively, the ports and government agencies are
referred to as the Strategy partners.
The voluntary actions in this Strategy Update are intended to complement regulations and,
together with the regulations, achieve the following emission reductions relative to a 2005
baseline:
Reduce diesel particulate matter (DPM) emissions per ton of cargo by 75% by
2015 and 80% by 2020, to decrease immediate and long-term health effects on adjacent
communities.
Reduce greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions per ton of cargo by 10% by 2015
and 15% by 2020, to limit contributions to climate change and reduce associated
environmental, health, and economic impacts.
These goals account for changing levels of port activity and focus on increasing efficiency per 
ton of cargo moved through the ports.
Since adopting the first Strategy in 2007, the Strategy partners have evaluated data and lessons 
learned from implementation efforts, advances in emission-reduction technology, and changes
in the regulatory landscape. This experience to date informs the Strategy Update and its key
elements:
Goals for reducing port-related emissions in the Georgia BasinPuget Sound airshed.
Performance targets for 2015 and 2020 for reducing emissions in each covered sector.
Pilot studies and demonstration projects to assess how new emission-reduction
technologies can help meet the emission-reduction goals.
The ports developed inventories of port-related air emissions in 2005 and updated their
emissions inventories in 2010 and 2011. The recent inventories show considerable progress
in reducing emissions since 2005, and they provide data to identify areas for continued                                            DRAFT
improvement going forward. The emissions inventories and the Strategy Update cover the
following sectors of port-related operations:
1. Ocean-going vessels
2. Harbor vessels
3. Cargo-handling equipment
1
DRAFT Northwest Ports Clean Air Strategy Update June 2013

4. Trucks
5. Locomotives and rail transport
6. Port administration
Table 1 summarizes the actions and performance targets in each sector of the Strategy Update
as presented in later chapters. Together, these performance targets are designed to achieve
the airshed emission-reduction goals by 2015 and 2020. The Strategy partners also committed
to conducting pilot studies and demonstration projects to advance innovative approaches to
reduce emissions from these sectors.
Table 1. Summary of Actions and Performance Targets by Sector for 2015 and 2020
Reduces
Sectors and Actions           2015 Targets    2020 Targets
DPM GHG
Ocean-Going Vessels
OGV-1
Vessels surpass Emission Control Area (ECA) Early compliance Ports track        
requirements                     with 2015 ECA   number of
0.1% fuel-      vessels with Tier
sulfur level (or   3 marine engines,
equivalent) while  shore power use,
hotelling before   cleaner fuel, or
2015        other emissionreduction
technologies
OGV-2
Ports and vessels participate in port-designed Ports and 10% of Ports and 40% of
or third-party certification programs that

vessel calls     vessel calls
promote continuous improvement (such as
Environmental Ship Index, Green Marine, Clean
Cargo Working Group, or others)
Harbor Vessels
Harbor-1
Strategy partners conduct annual outreach   Partners conduct  Partners conduct     
to port-related harbor vessel companies        outreach and 50% outreach and 90%
and recognize best practices and engine     of harbor vessel  of harbor vessel
upgrades                      companies report companies report
best practices and best practices and
engine upgrades  engine upgrades
Harbor-2 DRAFT
Ports and harbor vessels participate in port-  Ports and 10% of  Ports and 40% of     
designed or third-party certification programs  harbor vessels   harbor vessels
that promote continuous improvement (such as
Environmental Ship Index, Green Marine, Clean
Cargo Working Group, or others)
Continued >

DRAFT Northwest Ports Clean Air Strategy Update June 2013                                          2

Table 1. Summary of Actions and Performance Targets by Sector for 2015 and 2020 (continued)
Reduces
Sectors and Actions           2015 Targets    2020 Targets
DPM GHG
Cargo-Handling Equipment
CHE-1                                                
CHE meets Tier 4 interim (T4i) emission      50% of        80% of
standards or equivalent                  equipment      equipment
CHE-2                                                  
Ports and terminals have fuel-efficiency plans Ports and 50% of Ports and 100%
in place that promote continuous improvement   terminals       of terminals
Trucks
Truck-1
Trucks meet or surpass U.S. EPA emission   80% of trucks   100% of trucks   
standards or equivalent for model year 2007                 (by 2017)
Truck-2
Ports, terminals, and trucks have fuel-       Ports         Ports, terminals,     
efficiency plans in place that promote                      and 50% of
continuous improvement                            trucks
Locomotives
Rail-1
Switcher locomotive owners/operators                                
participate in a fuel-efficiency program      operators       operators 
institute a        achieve
program       performance
objectives of
chosen program
Rail-2
Switcher locomotive owners/operators      10% of        20% of          
upgrade or replace unregulated engines     unregulated    unregulated
(engine replacements will be Tier 2 or better)                DRAFT100% of owners/100% of owners/                          locomotive      locomotive
engines      engines
Continued >







3
DRAFT Northwest Ports Clean Air Strategy Update June 2013

Table 1. Summary of Actions and Performance Targets by Sector for 2015 and 2020 (continued)
Reduces
Sectors and Actions           2015 Targets    2020 Targets
DPM GHG
Port Administration
Admin-1
Ports own and operate cleaner vehicles and   Ports report    Ports increase       
equipment and have fuel-efficiency plans in   use of cleaner    use of cleaner
place that promote continuous improvement     vehicles and     vehicles and
equipment and   equipment
other relevant
information
Admin-2
Ports apply clean construction standards    Ports institute   Ports apply         
to engines used on port-led construction       clean          clean
projects (such as American Association of      construction    construction
Port Authorities, U.S. EPA Best Practices for     best practices for best practices for
Clean Diesel Construction, or equivalent best    port-led projects,  port-led projects,
management practices)                including idle-    including idle
reduction and Tier reduction and Tier
requirements    requirements
Admin-3
Ports facilitate energy studies and         Each port      Each port          
conservation projects at port-operated and/or   conducts 3     completes
tenant facilities to identify and address energy    energy studies    3 energy
conservation opportunities in building systems,                 conservation
operations, and yard lighting     DRAFT2 engine emission4 engine emission            projects









DRAFT Northwest Ports Clean Air Strategy Update June 2013                                          4

Limitations of Translatable Documents

PDF files are created with text and images are placed at an exact position on a page of a fixed size.
Web pages are fluid in nature, and the exact positioning of PDF text creates presentation problems.
PDFs that are full page graphics, or scanned pages are generally unable to be made accessible, In these cases, viewing whatever plain text could be extracted is the only alternative.