Minutes Exhibit A

oe       5
betpriean wey SR SET   TREurATVRi
TREEEE

of                               of            But -
6                                                 PORT    and  while sure    Sound    Is       and             have
C1                                                                                                                     raised enough  The      Now stocks
Carbon                                          I've burning    ember. That's a                     I                          River nthe
PaciFicFisHinG                                                                                                                     a
360-385-6138                                                                             acidifies    we  offers especially Scientists    these Chinook            worried,
are             fish      yachts fish kept      pollution This    front spreading lately,        Fluht                                                      calf
wood                                                      NW.                                  fish   anyone
salmon.                  still a  when                  to endangered too.    in   experienced coal,      why
down                                             far
in         have            that       row    the
A            say                     I    sockeye, mid-1980s,                                  dioxide can.      have   over          oil,  ballot will

CJ      8/PortTownsendShipwrightsCoop                                                                                Puget       chance they the to                                                   the
~                                                       fishing full                                 Just       sustain         Bristol       and         seat. beyond
ocToBeR               aluminum                                                          seroice  TOWNSEND      Sound. from    to first young  about                         dwindling,
dropped   surprised? three
themselves. Southern   replaced Bay,    some gas. degrades measure  vote
since                                        the
so                       Puget when   ocean    COMMENTARY
fleet                                                                                       I
10                                        for
2018
tackle            | Our years.
fish    like of    our
for               Scientists burning      enter                            while
what    Chinook   by was                                will      fishing consequences of Sound started
[J         www.ptshipwrights.com                                                               yard                      the   percent more
the
a resident    These Resident   boats                        a
fossil                                     back many
WWW.PACIFICFISHING.COM                ~                                                        over                at      might Sound.    of   teenager,               in       harm    waters: deeply Washington's    fleet.
steel                                                         servicing  SHIPWRIGHTS      the            themslves    than    orcas       orca    the home         carbon            fraying fishery seining
fuels    be                                                     Living
~                                                        three               UW       the November's    historic half.    eat    whales            fishermen         reduce
catch
was  with
Labs mixes                             whales    harbor. whale-watching I firsthand.    dioxide the Initiative    in marine
systems                                                      decades.                                                                                      my
the                   biggest   may  levels.
in                  Chinook and almost    haven't
into                                                                already dad
Friday            be                  aren't    Now   migrated Local      biggest 1631   Friday food        acidification:
the   problem ballot starving,    in                 they           (CO2)    in                                         Puget escapement exclusively   successfully getting                                     for
boats north. salmon    from source  Nov-    Harbor, web
Har- water       mea-                           are                        I are declining. Fraser   Yes
~
of                    to       we                                             Port
the China)    to low-income money  tax"      is    or  be      help that the            them to    also that      (and    boost         will    and                        Matt                              on
Not
world   Washington actually         This money hitting invested      fishermen Marine         initiative carbon Fishermen sheds    facilities coastal               This   money          The               slash
to
impose just          fuel         also
is                       Working measure,
a
for voters    will      diesel).
and                            charged      people means mechanism            more       benefit communities Initiative rejected         to
in                                        fishermen.
a                  association
mistargeted                             so    the
in                                                           fix   sticking help measure provided         Fishermen      every  confront
economy                       its
fix                                                                                                 Group
state
in
people. tax rejected fee-based                               revenues    ensure                                      go  emission solutions. That $15 wort fuels adapt the    includes                          2016.                       a                     the
and    fuel-efficient;    communities local
urban         1631's      much efficiency, the modest
fishermen    lot focusing   resource-dependent and             Marinkovich                                      Of Commission
isn't the                                                                                                             Initiative
breaks                                                                                                         attempt               on
and
for                                                                           root
to                                                        will of
have      problem       in policy directly      price per pay       money       are                                                      them
going                          ton
stable                                                        underlying    to
a              won't
Instead,
to    and                               on       tribal
for                                        fribes
local            2016.                       the                                                                           1631                                               October    Minutes
into targets, The rises of dime exempt    can collecting multiple be    water
Regular
and centers;    industries.           stronger,   problem "carbon                   "price    revenue    reduce                                     cause.                                with
already                                                                                              and         Seafood      CO2         the    also                  tion bor           23,
it -    big               at                                                                   achieve    carbon      leaders    does. "cure"      ness      fueling    called    aren't
governments
and                                                                           at
alone. isn't      This makes
Initiative business      emission   price $2 carbon      impacts. only         insisted         eliminate    businesses         fairer -  price" a                                              salmon.                Washington
more            layers                  The                          others    information    and            this       crab   plankton                  have                Exhibit
is                         dissolving                      Meeting    2018    A
that      time, way    which stops (per    at from
be revenue:    diverted   supplies protect                             on bigger   deep for                      impacts

of    on       retrofit   money  can invest"   giveaway)    emissions, investing               emissions, Energy, coastal intervened emissions. It
enacted                               (around                                                                                    a          and forcing    toxic High
Dozens
the expected

the
eaten
it   ton)    the      spent            and      trucking              approach                  this                       will
and it most fuel afford                      problem         harvest by algae CO2 pteropods,
extremes
and    more                  the       It's    and         vessels       use                                                                         shells to    measured
similar
a
that    where 1631                                to                       can                  to                                                                              BY
a                                          to        the people                                see that
of the    unfocused initiative sense reductions. should, rising a    fuel            accountability,   strong    carbon-storing           approach    that                        draw                                  bill.                        to                          emission article.              powerful         shellfish
endorsed      to       deserves   keep       salmon. that                                                                                                              year,  14    extra    reduce fee,                 fish build            than adapt. help fuels.    do                                          and major of
and                                            get                                     for
represent countries    dedicates               in    cents dock.                                  build                    This    cuts      only                                                           MATT
money                     with                                                                              a       and         beds.              tiny    most
"price-and-invest"               won't than    since 2035                                                     the
a                                                                            getting
Other carbon       not   squandered. measures down                                     their              improve                  closures
emissions a             forested vehicles hundreds cold                    Then       at
solutions provides   Washington      ordinary    initiative part,
initiative
low    the fisheries fair       affordable support       Scientists
warm prey
in Toxic displace               CO2-driven
*    the       if the               tax.                                  "carbon       it                                  worse               for floating generations. marine
Continued             the
about (including should    'rebates" give       most                             to                                                        this
revenue       "carbon      the   gallon              starting       carbon.    to of                                          shake.                      algae    waters
on                           of   proceeds of fuels price,      Legally,    Now                                     uses
or          ensure    water-    miles storages
costs.
Page         go?      away          state   gas  will            with the         make                                                                                              1631    MARINKOVICH
in that funding    voters tax"   people the will instead It    initiative trade The ballot    tool from    until say Dunge- are  nutritious are young  snails Itis waters acidifica-
half         to          the            so    to
7

by CASEY CAMPBELL and MIKE WELLS
Salmon hatcheries support Alaskans, feed the world
When the Good Friday earthquake shook Alaska in 1964, thedamage wasn't confined to buildings and homes. In
some
coastal areas, the land and ocean floor were uplifted, dramatically
impacting the productivity of aquatic habitat for decades.
For the fishing towns of Cordova and Valdez,thefertile salmon
spawning grounds of Prince William Soundall butdried up. But
this wasn't the end of the story.
The people of Cordova created the Prince William Sound Aqua-
culture Corp. (PWSAC). The nonprofit transformed
an old
cannery at Port San Juan into a prolific wild salmon hatchery. As
U.S. Sen. Ted Stevens recalled in the late 1970s, "In desperation,
the community of Cordova banded togetherto build
a major fish
hatchery, which was oneof the greatest community projects [ have  subsistencefishing revenue. The hatchery
program is a solution
ever witnessed in Alaska."                                         endowedto us by early Alaskans to meet the challenges of Alaska's
Around the same time, the Alaska Legislature introduced the  seafood industries and sustainably provide for the world's
Fisheries Rehabilitation, Enhancement, and Development (FRED)                                                         strong
demand for Alaska wild salmon. We should be working together
Division within the Alaska Departmentof Fish and Game, and fund-
to continuously improve our program as
we learn more about the
ing was provided to the department to construct hatchery facilities  natural environment and human interactions with it.
across the state and to staff them. Through the 1970s and '80s, FRED     Currently, there are many research projects related to Alaska
and the Sport Fish Division collaborated on
a numberof projects  salmon. In one major project, ADF&G and industry
statewide to improve opportunities for commercial and                                                                 are studying
sport users.   genetics, the scope of straying of hatchery-raised salmon, and
Shortly after opening the hatchery in 1974, PWSAC recorded  population fitness of interacting hatchery and wild salmon. This
the largest salmon run of
any hatchery in the world. The Alaska  project was developed to better help understand our salmon
seafood industry was once again working to meet the demands of
ecosystem in a way not possible before. Results of this study will chart
the global marketplace, as well as support the coastal economies of
a newpath for Alaska salmon, and the Alaska hatchery
Prince William Sound.                                                                                              program.
Research has found that hatcheries present a rare opportunity
In 1980, Valdez leaders in fisheries and business founded
to supplement our natural resources while limiting impacts
Valdez Fisheries Development Association Inc. and built the                                                           to
the environmentthat supports our fisheries. One of the biggest
Solomon Gulch Hatchery in Port Valdez in an effort to
support  challenges facing Alaska's salmon resource is that we love it too
the Valdez economy. The Solomon Gulch Hatchery would
later  much. It is clear that the demand for Alaska's wild salmon by all
become a consistent producer of early-run pink salmon
as well as  users is greater than what the natural environment
coho salmon, extending the common property fishery                                                            can support.
as well as  New solutions and research will be needed to determine how
significantly expanding sportfishing opportunities in Valdez. This  to sustain these runs as demand continues to increase and the
also led to the development of the annual silver salmon derby
in  environment continues to change.
Valdez, which has become an economic boon for the community.      Innovation and determination are the lifeblood of Alaska,
Hatcheries are the solution Alaska's founders intended for                                                             as was
us  etched in history by hardy Alaskans like those survivors of the
1964
to cultivate decades ago, whenfishing politics of the 1970sdiffered
earthquake. Thanks to them - along with Ted Stevens and other
little from the fish wars waged today. Back then, there
was still a  visionary leaders in Alaska's fisheries ~ the state's hatcheries play
strong desire to work together. When salmon runs collapsed, a  a vital role in ensuring the promise to future generations that they,
group of individuals representing various user groups joined to  too, can enjoyand benefit from healthy salmon stocks.
find waysto not only save our wild salmon but help them flourish
- To fulfill that promise, we must work together and rely
on sound
all while remaining dedicated to the environment and the  science. So, grab your pole, grab
your net, and help us carry on a
sustainability of Alaska's fisheries.                                 tradition older than Alaska itself. &
Fluctuating fish runs caused by natural cycles offer little stability
for Alaska's salmon users. Fisheries are the second-largest contributor  Casey Campbell is CEO ofPrince William Sound Aquaculture Corp. Mike
to Alaska's economyafteroil and gas, and history has found hatcher-  Wells is CEQ of Valdez Fisheries Development Association Inc. Learn
ies providereliable and sustainable salmon returns for all             more about salmon hatcheries statewide at salmonhatcheriesforak.org.
users.
Whether your favorite means of fishing is
sport, subsistence,
personal use, or you depend on commercial fishing for your liveli-
Marinkovich continued from Page 6
hood, hatchery-raised salmon have likely benefited
you and your
family. Recently, hatcheries have also divided those who depend on  policies. That's the kind of teamwork ittakes to make a difference.
salmon across our state. While some concerns should be addressed     Killer whales and fishermen share a common interest in making
and in many cases are,this is diverting our focus from finding       sure the ocean can continue to support the fish we hunt. We need
new
solutions to promote sustainable fisheries enhancementin Alaska.   a strong, fair policy that will cut emissions. We need
a policy like
Today, Alaska's economy is thriving due to the foresight of  Washington's Initiative 1631. &
manybefore us, and today many users depend on our fisheries  Matt Marinkovich grew upfishing sockeye salmon on Puget Sound,fishes
enhancement programs. Hatcheries generate hundreds of millions
Bristol Bay today, and runs Matt's FreshFish, selling direct to
consumers
of dollars in annual economic output, from commercial,
sport, and  and restaurants. He is an active advocatefor a healthy Salish Sea.

WWW.PACIFICFISHING.COM [] 0CTOBER 2018 [] PAcIFICFISHING [7
BE

Limitations of Translatable Documents

PDF files are created with text and images are placed at an exact position on a page of a fixed size.
Web pages are fluid in nature, and the exact positioning of PDF text creates presentation problems.
PDFs that are full page graphics, or scanned pages are generally unable to be made accessible, In these cases, viewing whatever plain text could be extracted is the only alternative.