6b
PORT OF SEATTLE MEMORANDUM COMMISSION AGENDA Item No. 6b ACTION ITEM Date of Meeting May 12, 2015 DATE: May 11, 2015 TO: Port of Seattle Commission Ted Fick, Chief Executive Officer FROM: Mike Merritt, Interim Chief of Staff SUBJECT: Terminal 5 interim use and City of Seattle Department of Planning and Development land-use interpretation ACTION REQUESTED Request the CEO to appeal to the City of Seattle Hearing Examiner Department of Planning and Development Director's Interpretation No. 15-001, formally issue on May 7, 2015, concerning the moorage of oil exploration vessels at Terminal 5. BACKGROUND "Big Ship Ready" Terminal 5 had been vacant since July 2014 with the termination of the lease agreement between the Port and Eagle Marine Services, Ltd, as the Port pursues the modernization and upgrade of the terminal. Including Terminal 5, efforts to make Port facilities "Big Ship Ready''include new larger cranes, strengthening of the pier, berth dredging and other improvements. Interim Usage The Port of Seattle has entered into a lease with Foss Maritime for the use of approximately 50 acres at Terminal 5. Foss MaritimeCompany, with Royal Dutch Shell as its customer,secured the property as a short-term berth for vessels used in oil and gas exploration in Alaska. Foss Maritime's intended use of theleased area atT-5 is to receive, inventory, and stage equipment and supplies that would be loaded to a fleet of vessels, including exploration drill rigs, ice-breakers, provisioning vessels, environmental response vessels, tugs and barges for seasonal operations in Alaska. The fleet of vessels would depart forAlaska in June and would likely return to Seattle around October, staying through May. The project began March of 2015 with a two year lease agreement, signed on February 9, 2015. On March 2, 2015, a coalition of conservation organizations filed a lawsuitagainst the Port of Seattle and the Port Commissioners, challenging the Port's entry into the lease with Foss Maritime. That lawsuit is expected to come to trial in 2016 and dispositive motions are scheduled for July 31, 2015. Template revised May 30, 2013. COMMISSION AGENDA May 11, 2015 Page 2 of 3 On March 24, the Commission unanimously adopted a motion to require explicit Commission approval for any extension of time for the Foss Maritime Lease, changes in the lease area, or other modifications of the lease. City of Seattle Land Use Interpretation On March 9, 2015, the City of Seattle announced that the Department of Planning and Development would review, investigate and determine whether the Terminal 5 interim use would be allowed under the terminal's Shoreline Substantial Development Permit. Upon the early March announcement of additional review by the city, the Port promptly responded to city requests for information about the T-5 project only days later, on March 13. Following a subsequentexchange of information, on May 7, 2015,DPD formally issued an interpretation that concluded the proposed moorage ofoil-exploration vessels and two support tugs is not consistent with the city's legally established cargo terminal use at Terminal 5 and that an additional permit is necessary. Subsequently, DPD clarified that under SMC 23.88.020 land use code interpretations are site specific. Thus, DPD Interpretation#15-001 cannot be directly applied to activities occurring at other Port facilities. Seattle Mayor Ed Murray, in a letter to the Port Commission on May 8, 2015, reiterated that theDPD Interpretation applied to the specific Terminal 5 use forthe three oil-exploration vessels alone. The Mayor offered to consider revisions in city regulations if they do not reflect historic, current or future uses at cargo terminals. Such changes in city regulations, however, could not be accomplished within the current schedule for the arrival of the Shell oilexploration vessels. Analysis by Port staff concludes unless a vessel meets with the City'sInterpretation of a "cargo vessel," it could not lay berth at Port cargo terminals. Since the Interpretation does not construe the Shell drilling rigs or support tugs to be "cargo vessels," these particular Shell vessels would not satisfy City code requirements for mooring at Terminal 5. Regardless of the city's follow-up communication, unless theInterpretation is further clarified, the Interpretation could be used in the future, by either the City or by business competitors of the Port's tenants and licensees, to challenge future moorage by these types ofvessels. The conclusion to theInterpretation states that an "additional use permit" is required, but the Interpretation does not identify what that permit might be. On May 8, 2015, Foss Maritime announced the company's intention to appeal the DPD Interpretation, citing impacts on Foss Maritime activities as well as potential conflictswith common maritime operational practices throughout the city. In many circumstances, the Port of Seattle considers lay-berthing and provisioning of vessels to be work critical to successful cargo operations. Examples of these activities include research vessels, fishing vessels, ice breakers, grain ship support vessels and fire response vessels. COMMISSION AGENDA May 11, 2015 Page 3 of 3 Summary of Proposed Motions for Commission Consideration As the city's Interpretation is inconsistent with the Port's historic operation of its cargo terminals and raises significant questions about the legality ofdiverse cargo activities at Port of Seattle cargo terminals, the Port of Seattle Commission directsthe Chief Executive Officerto appeal Interpretation No. 15-001 to the City of Seattle Hearing Examiner. ATTACHMENTS TO THIS REQUEST City of Seattle DPD Land Use Interpretation issued May 2, 2015 March 24, 2015 Port of Seattle Commission motion regarding Seaport Accountability May 8, 2015 letter from Diane Sugimura, DPD Director regarding T-5 interpretation May 8, 2015, letter from Mayor Ed Murray to the Port Commission May 8, 2015, statement from Foss Maritime concerning appeal of DPD interpretation Proposed Motion of the Port of Seattle Commission Regarding Review and Clarification of Seattle Department of Planning and Development Interpretation #15-001 PREVIOUS COMMISSION ACTIONS OR BRIEFINGS July 22, 2014, Lease termination agreement authorization for Terminal 5 May 13, 2014, Terminal 5 Facility Modernization Briefing January 13, 2015, Interim uses of Terminal 5 Briefing March 24, 2015, Adoption of Port of Seattle Commission motion regarding Seaport Accountability
Limitations of Translatable Documents
PDF files are created with text and images are placed at an exact position on a page of a fixed size.
Web pages are fluid in nature, and the exact positioning of PDF text creates presentation problems.
PDFs that are full page graphics, or scanned pages are generally unable to be made accessible, In these cases, viewing whatever plain text could be extracted is the only alternative.